Caste Based Reservation Policy of India:
Caste Based Reservation Policy of India:
To start off with, what exactly does a reservation policy do?
Reservations are provided so as to provide access to seats in multiple areas
including government jobs, educational institutions etc. India is a
multi-cultural country and the castes cannot be separated from the people. One
is recognized on the basis of the castes they belong to. There are certain
castes that are not on the same level as the others so reservations are
provided so as to maintain the equality. The striking question is whether these
reservations truly serve their purpose.
The government aims for adequate representation of the backward classes
and the advancement for the same. Reservations act as a tool to achieve the
same. These provisions are discussed under articles 15 and 16 of the Indian
Constitution. A study shows that almost 60% of the seats are reserved for the
backward sections of the society. These reservations also help to empower the
caste and ask for their active participation in the decision making. Though
these reservations are made, is it being used in the fair manner? Since almost
60% is reserved up, only 40% is available on merit which further more acts as a
hindrance. Caste based discrimination is not a new concept, it has been
practiced since many decades and the repercussions of them are still felt. In
India, instead of a class-based reservation it rather a caste-based
reservation. The castes instead of trying to come out of their shell try to
remain in it so as to gain additional benefits. Reservations is not the only
tool that can be adopted to ensure equality as in case of India it creates more
inequality. Ignoring the meritorious candidates for those with lesser academic
intelligence is inequality in the first place. Another major flaw is that these
reservations are only available at a higher level thus leaving out hundreds of
children who still cannot have their primary schooling. Politics also plays a
crucial role; the ‘adequate’ reservation number is not explicitly mentioned so
in states like Tamil Nadu where the backward populations predominate the
reservations went up to as much as 80% though the Supreme Court held the cap
for 50%. In educational institutes one can enter via the reservations but it
then becomes hard for the student to adapt to those situations. An instance was
seen wherein a Dalit student had committed a suicide as he was not able to cope
up with the academic pressure in IIT Mumbai.
Thus, caste-based reservations do not serve its purpose in entirety.
Social backwardness is a fluid concept and it cannot be made rigid. The poor
must be given this protection irrespective of what caste they belong to. The
issue of ‘creamy layer’ arises when divided on the basis of caste. It is not
right to spoon feed any particular section of the society but rather provide
the people with adequate tools so that they can sustain themselves. The
weakening of the correlation between ‘economically backward’ and ‘lower caste’
must be taken into consideration.
Comments
Post a Comment